The first comes from Capt. Thomas A. Walker of the 63rd, Superintendent of Freedmen, West Tennessee. He is reporting to Lieutenant Jno. F. Perry, Adjutant Freedmen Department, May 31, 1864. In addition to the camp at President's Island, he reports on Camp Holly Springs and Shiloh.
Of President's Island, he writes that in the interest of the camp and to ensure "the dignity and integrity of our organization," he has placed Jno. C. Walker [his brother], who is of Co. K of the 63rd, in charge of the Island. "Under his administration," Capt. Walker reports, "every resource is developing finely." Capt. Walker continues that the agricultural program is experiencing success with "vegetables coming into market." "The farm is," he reports, "in splendid condition." With these successes, "a spirit of unity and mutual confidence pervades the camp."
It may be worth noting that in John Eaton's report of 1864 (published in 1865), his view of the experiment at President's Island seems somewhat less positive (than Thomas's) due to the usurpation of power by the Treasury. It is also interesting that Capt. Walker's report begins with a note of frustration concerning vagrant freedpeople within the city. He laments that there are many such persons who have circumvented the pass system and by so doing found their own places of residence (he implies at exorbitant prices) and their own employments including thievery. He finds such freedpeople a "nuisance" and believes that they will be better off in camp. In accordance with a circular he indicates was issued by the Adjutant of the Freedmen [sic] Department, he reports that he has sent vagrants "and those guilty of offences, to the Island camps."**
Another report comes from Surgeon D.O. McCord, Medical Director and Inspector of Freedmen, also enlisted in the 63rd. June 28, 1864, Dr. McCord reports that Memphis had "two camps and two hospitals, one of which was for small pox cases." Dr. McCord writes that he was first assigned to the care of freedmen but later took on a more general duty, leaving the people with only two surgeons and a number of hospital stewards detailed by Maj. Gen. Grant. One of the two acting assistant surgeons was, according to Dr. McCord, put in charge of the General Hospital and the other in charge of President's Island. Camp Holly Springs and the small-pox hospital were left, according to Dr. McCord, without surgeons. However, he also reports that in February he wrote to the Western Sanitary Commission, the N.W. Freedmen Aid Commission, and Western Freedmen Relief Commission asking for assistance. The Freedmen Aid Commission, McCord writes, sent "ten surgeons and some vegetables." One of the ten surgeons was sent to President's Island.
McCord comments that the improvements at President's Island are more "marked" than he has seen elsewhere in his tour of camps in the Valley. "It is nicely policed," he writes, and the quarters appear comfortable although the hospital is in need of repair. He made an order for improvements.
"Extracts" also contains much information on Freedmen's Schools throughout the Valley. A report on schools on President's Island (January to June, 1865) includes this:
"During the first three months no reports were received, and during March the overflow of the island stopped the schools almost completely. This fact, combined with the return of the best half of the island to its original owner, caused the authorities to remove all the soldiers, and the self-supporting portion of the camp, to other localities, during the last of April and the first week in May."In light of the above, one wonders what to make of Maj. Gen. N.J.T. Dana's Special Order No. 10, which effectively removed from President's Island "all white persons not directly connected with the military service." The order was effective January 1, 1865.
*Grant's papers reference November 13, 1862 as the date of Eaton's appointment while Special Order No. 15 dates the appointment at November 11, 1862.
**Note that Thomas reference to more than one Island camp. Perhaps this, combined with the captain's dubiousness, suggests that there was a camp for vagrants and one for enterprising blacks interested in farming and gardening; both may have been on President's Island.